Posts Tagged ‘comparison’

Baltimore – iPhone 5

©TimeLine Media - Graphic design on side of car hauler

I felt bad about the comparison I made last week comparing the iPhone 5 images to a Nikon D4, a full-frame DSLR. Although, I was testing the limits of the smart phone camera that early in the morning without much help from any natural light. So today I will post some photos from bright, sunny conditions. This will show what it can do in very bright light. Comparatively, this should even the competition. This is not the “best” light for photos. Most of these are in the middle of the day without many clouds in the sky. Addtionally the sun is almost directly overhead. Portraits would not look very good in this light. However buildings, structures and other non-faces can be done. Additionally, with some post-processing they can look decent even from the iPhone.

iPhone Comparison

©TimeLine Media - Baltimore Transamerica Tower with iPhone
©TimeLine Media – Baltimore Transamerica Tower with iPhone
©TimeLine Media - Bank of America Building & William Donald Schaefer Building with iPhone
©TimeLine Media – Bank of America Building & William Donald Schaefer Building with iPhone

Baltimore, MD has the tallest buildings in the state of Maryland. Just a few blocks off the Inner Harbor, and you are in the canyons of streets lined with these buildings. Having plenty of overhead sun and no clouds in the sky are emphatically perfect conditions for a point and shoot or smartphone camera to perform it’s best. The smaller sensor in these devices require much more light than larger cameras, so these images are almost as good as what they can produce.

Indycar Paddock

©TimeLine Media - Graphic design on side of car hauler
©TimeLine Media – Graphic design on side of car hauler

With just a touch of clarity and contrast, the graphics painted onto the side of this truck are and the sharpness of the text in the license plate are indistinguishable from images taken with any other camera. The bright light in the area means that there is no camera shake from slow shutter speeds. Especially when taking photos of dark subjects, the smartphone camera will compensate for the lack of light by increasing the shutter speed which is very difficult to hold still without introducing shake. These cameras were not designed to be mounted on a tripod, and are hard to hold steady for very long. Give a scene lots of light, though, and that problem goes away.

With the low ISO settings in the bright light, vivid colors can be reproduced. In this last photo, the bright red paint on this hauler is faithfully reproduced. Adding more Clarity in Lightroom is the only adjustment needed to finish this image. If only the iPhone were able to write the RAW data from the sensor, it could be a viable replacement in the right situations!

©TimeLine Media - detail of racing hauler
©TimeLine Media – detail of racing hauler

TimeLine Mediawww.timelinedc.com
703-864-8208

iPhone Photography Comparison

©TimeLine Media - Day Lilly - macro

As far as experience goes, I am new to the iPhone. It is impressive as a phone as well as computer for connecting to the internet. But the photography capabilities are quite a force to be reckoned with as having a camera on hand all the times has changed how we make and share photos. Facebook and it’s acquired company, Instagram, have boomed in popularity with emphasis on sharing photos. I distinctly remember the first event where I saw people using cell phones to capture photos. I did not think this trend would stick, but boy was I wrong! As of today, the iPhone holds the top 3 spots of the most popular camera used to post to Flickr.

Camera Comparison

In my short time using the camera on the iPhone 5, I have been impressed. The camera built into the phone performs much better than some dedicated point and shoot cameras I have seen. When I the day lilies in the back of the house bloomed, I decided to compare the camera in my phone to my Nikon D4. What can a DSLR give you over your camera phone?

Here are some photos from the iPhone-

©TimeLine Media - Day Lilly - iPhone
©TimeLine Media – Day Lilly – iPhone
©TimeLine Media - Day Lilly - iPhone
©TimeLine Media – Day Lilly – iPhone

With the bright, overcast light the phone performs very well! The in-camera sharpness and color from the JPG file is really good. When I took out the DSLR, I found that it was easier to find a good composition. The phone has a fixed lens that is slightly wide in length (roughly 33mm according to spec sheets). With the DSLR, I used a 105mm macro lens. It makes isolating subjects from the background easier, and can focus closer than the lens on the phone. Here are some examples from that combination-

Macro lens on DSLR

©TimeLine Media - Day Lilly - macro
©TimeLine Media – Day Lilly – macro

In looking at the photos now, I can see that this is not the best comparison. I should try next time to get equivalent focal lengths, but I that may be the point! The DSLR and it’s ability to change lenses, gives you more flexibility in making images. If the composition you are looking for cannot be made at 33mm, you are stuck. I wanted to have the flower be the subject without seeing the surrounding ground and concrete patio in the frame. With the DSLR, I didn’t even see these in the viewfinder. Adding a touch of flash, I was able to take out more of the background, and really have the flower pop out of the frame-

©TimeLine Media - Day Lilly - macro
©TimeLine Media – Day Lilly – macro

Since I had the macro and the flash out there, I tried to get a shot of a droplet on the flower at the minimum focus distance of the lens. This took a lot of timing and patience as any slight breeze took the droplet out of focus. Here is one that was actually sharp!

©TimeLine Media - Day Lilly - macro
©TimeLine Media – Day Lilly – macro

Just for fun, here is a 100% crop from the center of the frame. Makes the flower photo very abstract with a natural vignette from the shape of the flower petals. Plus the reverse reflection of the flower in the droplet was an unexpected surprise!

©TimeLine Media - Day Lilly - macro
©TimeLine Media – Day Lilly – macro

TimeLine Media – www.timelinedc.com
703-864-8208